1. Governance in a Micro-Urban Community
There is a new trend among the
emerging urban communities to acquire the collective status of an association
to institutionalise their relations among themselves and with others. Our
Constitution recognises the right to associate and to function as an
association as a distinct legal entity of its own. In general, all civil
society organizations are nongovernmental and are composed of active citizens
who voluntarily participate to improve some specific aspects of governance of
human relations. Among them, we are specifically interested in highlighting
those newly-formed micro-urban communities which strive for the integral
development of diverse residents who happen to come together to live together
in an urban locality in an interdependent manner with aspirations for a higher
quality of life.
They
are democratic societies, as some among them are elected by the residents as
Representatives to operate autonomously within the community as a
self-governing organisation, and also cooperate with the outside authorities
for development in many if not all aspects of the general welfare. The
managers of these bodies can deal with all organs of the state i.e. executive,
legislature and judiciary and at all levels of government i.e. municipal, state
and central. They have no vested interest except the common
good, and they do not receive
funds from the governments for their survival. Nor do they seek power to make
changes in the society; but they use their soft power of voluntary commitment
backed by knowledge and experience to influence the decision-makers in the
above three tiers of governments. They have been working with other civil
society organisations and NGOs in the area, such as senior citizens
associations, women's groups, ‘Basthi Committees', etc. to tackle social
issues, such as slums, begging, orphans and the destitute, elderly, women
safety, rowdyism, forced collections, street violence, contagious diseases,
epidemics, relief work in case of natural or man-made disasters, etc. We have
seen the crucial role played by them during the COVID-19 epidemic.
In other words, a Resident Welfare
Association (RWA), reflects the common interests of an entire micro-urban
community residing in a specific area, formed as a cooperative housing
society or a layout of a colony welfare association with several households or
a building consisting of several apartments. From a democratic point of view,
they function like a mini-government and are responsible to those
who have elected them to fulfill
certain tasks specified in the memorandum of the Association, which is
registered as a legal entity. The Executive Committee manages an annual budget
with income from the members as charges for maintenance or other collective
activities and incurs expenditure to attend to the common needs as well as the
general welfare of the residents. Their financial transactions
are audited and approved annually
by the general assembly of the members and are recorded by the Registrar of
Societies. They pay taxes upon some of their activities and employ limited
number of people for sanitation, as watchmen, security guards, domestic help,
gardeners, etc. Ideally, they have to function as cooperative housing
societies, as they exist in Mumbai, and partner with the government as it
appened under the Bhagidari system in New Delhi. They are called community
governments in the USA and regional governments in China. Therefore, to
promote self-reliance and self-management of material and human resources
locally at the municipal ward level, we would like to see that these bodies be
treated as the 4th tier of self-governance, after the Union, state and
municipal governments.
2. Inclusive and Harmonious
Community for All Ages
While the first generation of RWAs
have been helping to solve many problems which are technical and
administrative, the new generation of Indian RWAs distinguish themselves
by aiming, in addition, at a noble mission. The Indian families residing in
urban areas can now easily go beyond courteous good neighbourly attitude
towards others and regain some of the benefits of the erst while joint-family
relations of caring and sharing for each other.
An apartment-building is an extended joint family composed of several small families. Many residents in these blocks or flats learn the necessary social skills and help their children too to acquire them as a prerequisite for harmonious living with their external social and natural environment. In this micro-community all the families come into contact with other families every day, across the corridor, in the lane or within the neighbourhood. It is the only community where all the members physically gather in meetings and see others eye to eye. Social media devices like Whats App groups help them to find time, as well as the opportunities to improve their instantaneous communications, and to take quick decisions. They are making a conscious effort to build open and humane society, where the individual's freedom is respected, and where women count as equally active partners. Youth from the small families will not be alienated and will not search for excitement from outside groups and drug gangs, as they would find readily available good companions in the peer groups within the community. Composed of much social diversity of castes, religions, languages, regions and states, these 'mini Indias' in evitably promote harmonious inter-cultural living among all the residents who came together to live together by choice or by coincidence.
Understanding and tolerating each
other and rendering mutual help and support is a sheer necessity for them.
While in the past, large family units tried to live autonomously and
self-sufficiently, today's small families need their neighbours for their
mutual needs and for their emotional expressions, be it force liberating a
happy event or for expressing grief. In their meetings, the members cannot
often make irresponsible criticism or the majority cannot bulldoze the minority
opinions, as they need the cooperation of all and as their common interest is
at stake. Hence, they are obliged to take decisions by consensus, in spite of
differences and persuade to obtain compliance by all, as in the UN-related
bodies.
3. No, The RWAs Are Not Yet ‘Utopias.’
During the COVID-19 emergency in the country, while
noting the indispensable and unavoidable role played by them in the urban
communities in general, none the less, the occasion has exposed and revealed
their weaknesses as well. Some managers of RWAs are tempted to
exhibit their 'fortress' mentality and are accused to have behaved like little
Hitlers or little Polpots. As these residents are originally new settlers from
villages, initially they wanted to build kinship in the locality by attracting
the people from the same caste or same religion or same region, or same mother
tongue, or those who worked in the same department or belonging to the
profession. This is not an abnormal behaviour, as a similar thing had happened
in Israel when they, in the fifties had initiated the collective communities,
called 'kibbutz'. It is evident that gradually the residents change, as
generations change and also as people from different cultural backgrounds join
the community, unavoidably.
Internally, they tend to show a strong sense of
private property and jealously fight for the protection of the
common spaces belonging to the association, just like an
individual family. Some exhibit 'border mentality' regarding their
physical 'layout' towards neighbouring ‘layouts’, and they treat others as
outsiders not eligible to enjoy the benefits of the assets within their colony
or building. No doubt, they have often their justification. Many presidents,
secretaries and treasurers are reluctant to pass on their posts to other
residents, as a matter of rotation. Many office-bearers behave with a
‘head-of-the-family’ attitude; they are yet to become whole-heartedly
accountable, transparent and open to criticism. Financial management and
passing on the accounts to the next team is always a source
of misunderstandings and friction. Strongly influenced by the
prevailing political culture, many tend to establish power hierarchies among
the members, abhor non-selective socialization and cultivate groupism. Strongly
motivated by a sense of efficiency and to save their time, they do
not mind handing over small ‘mamools’ and bribes to the lower level
staff of the Administration. They use personal relations of highly-placed
persons to send telephonic calls to the higher officials to make the
stuck up files move.
Yet, in spite of these rumblings and grumblings, inevitable in a transforming society, the association is a school of democracy to learn to self-govern the affairs of the community. Out of this churning and turbulence will emerge slowly the cardinal values of liberty, equality, fraternity and legality. The residents are constantly involved in dialogue and multi-lateral communications that are imposed forever by the proximity. They will go on enlarging the areas of social cooperation and team work in the management of their personal affairs thanks to Social Media. The residents would go on discovering the neighbour's inherent worth and merit without trying to guess his or her caste or religion or region, and enrich themselves mutually in inter-personal relations.
4. Relations
with the Municipality or the Corporation
A. Some national and state-level federations of the
RWAs are to be recognised as the nodal agencies by the Principal Secretary of
the Ministry of Municipal Administration and Urban Development. They can play
an advisory role to decentralise many governmental activities so as to avoid
wastage and bring more efficiency into areas of waste management, fighting
water, soil and air pollutions, municipal services in health, education and
culture, and in protecting the infrastructure.
B. The RWAs alone can enlist peoples’
organized participation in various local schemes, programmes and projects. The
RWAs can rightly boast of having many eminent residents like retired
vice-chancellors, professors, scientists, lecturers, teachers, judges, lawyers,
chartered accountants, doctors, engineers, technicians, C.E.O.s, M.D.s and
managers of reputed firms, and many former bureaucrats, who can now advise and
participate freely without any constraints in the Ward-level committees.
C. Representatives of zonal federations of
RWAs can be co-opted to each Municipal Council so that they can be particularly
involved in the city development plans and master plans.
D. Periodic consultations with the RWAs can be held
at the level of the Deputy Commissioner, Zonal Commissioner and the
Commissioner to review the progress made in resolving the issues raised by the
RWAs.
E. Meritorious RWAs are to be recognised
on Independence day/ Republic day celebrations for awards by the
Mayor and the Commissioner, for the greenest flat or house, best park, best
water body, cleanest community, etc.
F. Aasara, a unique parity association of
officials and the senior citizens formed and registered by the Greater
Hyderabad Municipal Corporation to oversee all the welfare activities of the
municipal corporation concerning the elder population is a good model to be
adopted by every municipality.
G. Since the Councillor or Corporator is
democratically elected to be in charge of the entire area and for all the
residents, it should be given unstinted support, irrespective of her or his
political affiliation, and should be very closely associated in all the
relations with the municipality.
5. Local Co-Management with the
Municipality
A. The spirit of democratization of our political
system demands that the power of decision-making be decentralised, as much as
possible, so as to permit active citizens to take part in it. The Ward
Committee is an institution mentioned in the Constitution after the 1994
Constitutional Amendment. The members are to be drawn from the local residents
active in the civil societies,
without any party affiliations. The RWAs can
mobilize and propose enthusiastic and competent senior citizens, women, youth
and other eminent residents to be involved in micro-planning, maintenance of
the local infrastructure and for field coordination of the works of various
departments.
B. The RWAs are already very active in the
Green Action Plan and its maintenance in the area. Apart from the plantation in
public places, they are particularly helping in greenery in the interiors of
the habitations.
C. Any slum improvement effort on the part of the
local, state or national authorities should logically join hands with the
neighbouring RWAs. The growth of slums, inevitable in an increasingly
urbanising nation, is none the less a blot on the urban society. Since most of
the slums are formed by the side of the RWAs and most of the slum-dwellers work
in the houses, shops and offices of the nearby residents, the slum-dwellers
observe with envy the middle-class lifestyles and gradually adapt them. Their
second generation gets very naturally integrated socially into the urban life
and shift away from the slum area, thereby leaving room for new immigrants from
the villages. They take on rent a portion in a house in a colony or a flat in
the apartment building meant for low-income groups, and thereby become
full-fledged members of the RWAs. The RWAs can make
conscious efforts to make this process happen more smoothly since an
RWA is an inclusive community.
D. Local public works carried out in the lanes and
streets, like laying roads, pavements, lighting, etc. should get the
endorsement of satisfactory completion by the RWA members. This would reduce
much wastage of materials, low quality of execution and corruption in the engineering
works in any municipality.
E. In all field work, the departmental staff on the
visit can seek the cooperation of the Ward Committee more systematically for
Third-Party Audit, census, surveys, tax collection, etc.
F. The RWAs have to play necessarily the most
important role in the local disaster-preparedness and in applying the Standard
Operating Procedures during epidemics, disasters and other emergencies.
G. The RWAs should appeal to the RERA State
Committee to setup a 'Conciliation and Dispute Resolution Cell’ within the
State Committee, as suggested by RERA Act and to include RWAs in it. This will
reduce many encroachments and irregular building constructions in the area.
H. The RWAs should approach the
establishments that deal with local Law & Order, Water, Electricity,
Health, Education, Planning, Transport, etc., in order to have periodical
consultations not only to offer their suggestions and to lodge their complaints
but also to participate in the local management.
I. Where needed, they can facilitate the proper
functioning of the local post office and their accessory services to all the
residents.
6. Safety & Security in the Locality
A. Since the RWAs carryout community policing
(24hx7days) with the help of watchmen and security guards in all lanes, streets
and buildings, there should be regular training sessions in skills for
the hired personnel to be efficient, respectful and helpful in all situations,
as well as to train them to act judiciously in emergency situations.
B. Separate space has to be provided for young
people to form youth clubs, etc. and to gather and to spend time together in an
organised and transparent way, without having to hang around in the streets,
aimlessly.
C. The RWAs should regularly be in touch with the
nearest Police stations in order
i) to indicate the points of visit and to sign the
visit-book by the night Patrolling vehicles,
ii) to convene meetings with the police officials
during festival processions, such as ‘Ganesh Pooja’ to see that they take place
peacefully and without adding to the pollutions, iii) to encourage them to form
committees for public cooperation, such as Maitri Committees or Voluntary
Committee for Senior Citizens,etc.
D. The managers of the Associations should visit
the local institutions of public utility like the clinics, hospitals, schools
and nurseries to ensure that they function in order, security, tranquility and
efficiently.
E. In the care of the senior citizens, in the
Apartment RWAs, the visitors to the seniors are screened by the watchmen. In
emergencies, their neighbours in the corridor would attend to them. Their where
abouts in the building or in the public spaces are traced in the CCTV cameras
and some of the cameras are connected to the Police Stations. The community
halls, Elders' Day-Care centres, parks, clubs, gymnasiums, walking tracks,
swimming pools maintained by the RWAs provide ample avenues to suit the needs
of the senior citizens. Senior citizens' associations are often hosted in the
premises of the RWAs.
7. Community of Urban Consumers
Just as
political rights are important for all citizens in the country, economic rights
are also important for all the residents to improve the quality of their
living. They are a body of consumers of innumerable number of services
and products supplied by the government departments, public sector
undertakings, Multi-National Corporations, private enterprises of different
sizes, cooperative societies and street vendors. Individually no
consumer-resident can afford to deal with the powerful establishments in case
of a problem.
Consumer education i.e. product-knowledge and its application without damage to
the health or to the Nature is possible only collectively, and it is
particularly so to the low income groups among the residents. In case of a
dispute, the Association can take up the issue efficiently for solution without
any ideological bias or any extraneous considerations, since it is composed of
men and women professionals of several disciplines like lawyers, CAs, doctors,
engineers, company managers, businessmen, government officers. Further, outside
their community, almost all of the residents work as producers and suppliers in
the above mentioned establishments and enterprises.
A. The RWAs raise funds from the residents as
membership fees and as maintenance and user charges. In addition, they collect
funds to undertake major works of common interest. In the beginning, all
owners invest not only in the house or the flat that they buy but also in the
necessary infrastructure for ready access and amenities, which they are, in
principle, entitled to expect from the municipalities and state departments, in
course of time.
B. Many courts have characterized their economic
transactions as economy of mutuality in cooperative spirit. They can take up
many more activities directly than at present on cooperative principles of
management for bulk shopping of goods and services needed by the residents, and
get them delivered individually. For example, milk, vegetables, fruits, pulses
and other grocery items and their delivery to individual residents could be
arranged with direct links with the nearby rural producers who can directly
sell their products without middlemen. This arrangement would give higher
income to rural households and controls seasonal and irrational escalation of
prices of essential items for urban consumers. It further brings
stability to the essential consumer products index (CPI).
C. As stakeholders, they can protect and maintain
parks, tanks, open places, etc. in their area, when entrusted to them on a
contract basis.
D. They can provide and maintain bus stands, car
and cycle parking and auto-stands.
E. The Ration shops and other public distribution
and servicing centres that are located in the area can be supervised by the mas
consumers or as Third Party auditors.
F. RWA members are to be part of the local Basthi
Dawakhana management committee, Sanitation committee, Environment committee,
Slum-Improvement activities, etc., where they can provide logistic support.
G. RWAs are to be formally associated with all tax
collections, including the property tax, with the understanding that a percentage
of the receipts are to be spent on local works desired by the RWAs.
H. Local commercial establishments like shops of
meat and fish, weekly markets, street vendors should be watched regarding the
quality and measures and be guided to render better services to the residents,
without the assistance of the inspectors and police. Some such activities could
eventually be financed and the management can be shared by the RWAs.
(i). Some of such commercial establishments and
their personnel should be included and involved in the activities of the
Association, as they reside or live in the area.
(ii) The RWAs can draft and get signed a suitable
‘Community Pact’ with the local establishments as a memorandum of
agreement or a pact between the suppliers of goods and services and the
residents' association to defend each other’s interests as there is
mutual dependence. The Association offers their continued patronage,
facilities and security, safety and protection
against forced collection of 'chandaas' etc. and the other party assures the
supply of quality goods and services in transparency i.e. at affordable prices,
without indulging in adulteration and other unethical practices.
(iii). They cooperate with the local banks and
insurance company branches and their agents for equal access and equitable
services to all.
I. RWAs should be given preference to install and
manage common services in the area, like Automatic Cash Machines,
Coffee-machines, Washing machines, snacks-machines, photocopying machines,
cyber-cafes, reading rooms and e-libraries, e-service- centres,
gymnasiums, swimming pools, day-care centres for
children and the senior citizens, street cleaning, garbage collection, and to
collect user-charges where necessary.
J. They should be authorized to permit, negotiate
and collect income from advertisements or publicity within not only their
premises but also in the area.
K. Holding sessions of Yoga, dance, music,
painting, cooking, etc. and holding classes for learning many social and
mechanical skills for reparation of many household gadgets as well as for
healthcare services can be organized in the community halls on user charges.
Nurseries and summer-classes for children should be
one of the priority areas of concern for the managers of the RWA.
L. Holding sports & games and other cultural
events can be held in the child care centres, seniors' day-care centres, and in
the community halls and other local common places or open spaces, with the
support of the municipal corporation.
M. It is to be hoped that in the long term, funding
given to the RWAs would be one of the factors that would be considered in the
financial allocations by the Finance Commissions, in its financial devolution
to the municipalities. This is to some extent happening in the NOIDA area,
without it being pronounced as such.
8. Cooperation with Other Civil Society
Organisations & Institutional Support:
Urban
communities consist of not only individuals and families but also social
institutions and civil society organisations, which tackle social issues and
watch over vulnerable groups and categories among the residents. The RWA
cooperates with the locally operating senior citizens associations, old age
homes, Mahila Mandalis and other social organisations and other NGOs like the
Red Cross, Lions and Rotary Clubs, etc. They mobilize voluntary services and
funds for local welfare.
A. Climate change is a concern that cannot be
ignored by the urban residents. Among them water pollution, air pollution and
sound pollution have to be tackled by the RWAs by co-opting or inviting
regularly a resident /scientist who is qualified or knowledgeable about
environment concerns, or a local NGO, to the Executive Committee to advise on
the best practices to be adopted and observed in the area.
B. Residents as Consumers: Since
the residents are consumers of goods and services provided by the public sector
establishments as well as the private sector, their quality, cost-effectiveness
and access are to be ensured by the RWA with appropriate tools for testing,
making suggestions and lodging complaints.
C. Further, the RWA management will make use of the
RTI Act and seek appropriate channels for grievance redressal in favour of the
residents, when needed. On issues that concern several residents, land
disputes, encroachment of roads and water-bodies, irregular building
constructions, etc., they might resort to judicial proceedings, such as Public
Interest Litigation (PIL).
D. Capacity-Building of RWAs: Many urban residents
are professionals rich in 'human capital' like knowledge, experience,
digital expertise, skills of communications and management with innovative
genius, and would be willing to invest a part of their time and money for
better functioning and management of the RWAs. They observe the 23rd November,
as the 'RWA Day' in their Executive Committee meeting or the General Assembly
to reflect on the role of the Association to further improve the quality of
life of the residents.
E. Since the mission of an RWA is living together
harmoniously with the neighbour, their networking and their local and regional
federations should aim at treating the world as one family and work in favour
of international understanding and universal peace.
9. Cooperation with the State Election Commissioner
and the Chief Election Commissioner of India
A. The RWAs alone can help in efficient preparation
and updating of the Electoral Rolls, and they can endorse the revision and
deletion of names, etc.
B. The RWAs can facilitate and support the functioning
of the Polling Stations and booths in their community halls and local schools,
etc. in a permanent way.
C. The RWAs are observing the 25th January for
Systematic Voters' Education and Electoral Participation (SVEEP) in cooperation
with the Chief Electoral Officer. On occasions, Memorandum of Agreement, MOUs
are signed between the ECI and RWAs.
D. They arrange and provide a common platform for
all the candidates to introduce themselves before the residents seeking their
vote before all elections, and thereby reduce some practices of the candidates
which are not in conformity with the Election Code of Conduct.
E. These activities of the RWAs are becoming effective to ensure a higher percentage of voting by the urban residents.
0 Comments